Collingwood vs. Western Bulldogs – Qualifying Final Match Review

Colliingwood – 17.22 (124)
Western Bulldogs – 8.14 (64)

Save for a brief period in the 3rd quarter, Collingwood have smashed the Bulldogs in a rather expectant fashion in a greasy Melbourne night that threatened to be so much worse.

The Bulldogs started off rather well with their pressure at the contest but just could not sustain it. They also allowed Collingwood to play the game on their terms with relative ease which pretty much decided the game.

WIth the margin blowing out to 32 points at half-time and Bulldogs not looking like to score easily, the game was pretty much over and became a bit of a training drill for the Pies.

Key Players for Collingwood

Dale Thomas – In his best year in AFL, probably his best game. Played a brilliant 4 quarter game handling the ball like it was dry whilst also gaining a heap of metres with some long effective kicking. Finished with 32 touches and a goal.

Dane Swan – One of the better Finals performances you’ll see this series with his 39 touches, 6 clearances and 3 goals. He’s primed for a good few weeks…..

Nick Maxwell – Dominated down back in the first half after bizarrely being let to stay by himself whilst his man Jarrod Harbrow went looking for kicks upfield. He help set up the nice lead at half-time with his excellent reading of the play.

Key Players for Western Bulldogs

Ryan Griffen – Played like a man possessed, especially in the first half where he had something like 8 possessions in the first 5 minutes. If a few more of his team mates played with the same endeavour, the game may have been different. Finished with 34 touches. He wasted a bit of them, but a lot of them were under intense pressure.

Robert Murphy – Played very well behind the ball and through his ball use, the Bulldogs were able to set up some rare good attacks from the back.

Musings from the Match

  • The weather was a bit of a non-event to be honest. It did pour down for about an hour but stopped about 30 minutes before the bounce.
  • It was an extremely even performance from Collingwood.
  • Obviously, it’s in stark contrast for the Bulldogs with only a few that can keep their heads held high.
  • Other notable mentions for the Pies include Ben Reid, Luke Ball and Scott Pendlebury.
  • Their forward-press was in full flight at times. Bad news for the other teams.
  • The Bulldogs disposal efficiency was pretty woeful for the night, only managing 61% team-wide.
  • Jarrod Harborw was one of the worst offenders with his 33% for the night.
  • His poor use of the ball was compounded in the importance of his direct opponent (Nick Maxwell) having a massive influence on the game.
  • The Bulldogs just looked like a class below.
  • Leon Davis had another poor final if you’re wondering.
  • It’s no real surprise given that they are missing on of their best midfielders and defenders.
  • The Doggies now have to play the winner of Sydney & Carlton in next weeks Elimination Final
  • The Pies play the winner of Geelong & Fremantle now in the Preliminary final.
  • Tags: , , , ,

    Vish is one of the original members of the ContestedFooty team. He is also a proud Collingwood supporter but thankfully for us he can keep both eyes open when it comes to football.

    Vish has written 230 articles for ContestedFooty

    Stay Up-to-date

    Never miss a big story again by subscribing to us by RSS, email or twitter.

    subscribe to footy RSS AFL email updates Follow the AFL blog's twitter

    5 Responses to “Collingwood vs. Western Bulldogs – Qualifying Final Match Review”

    1. Mark says:

      Will Big Bad Barry get sidelined in a crucial week?

    2. alec says:

      how about punching someone in the throat?
      he wont get suspended because the afl wont let it happen: its a bad image for the game…

      think putting someone in a headlock and getting off scott free…

    3. Matt says:

      Will be a small amount of karma if Barry Hall doesnt play against Sydney.

      After wrecking 2years with his stupid antics, it would almost be fitting if his new team had to win without him!

      I think Sydney can win either way though with all the other issues the Bulldogs have right now

    4. Jon Jon says:

      Good write up, and hard to read as a Doggies fan.

      Didn’t really blame Hall for firing up at Harry O, trying to stand over Bazza after you lay a pretty nice shepherd isn’t really the smartest idea.

      Hall was appropriately withdrawn though and didn’t snot him in the face!

    Leave a Reply